• Home
  • NE100
  • Features
  • Brand Voice
  • Innovation
  • Leadership
  • public policy
  • collection
  • Video
    • Current issue
    • Magazine issue undefined
Echelon logo
  • Features
  • Portfolio
  • Brand-voice
  • Innovation
  • Leadership
  • Public-policy
  • Collection
  • Videos
86,000 People Pay 80% of Personal Income Tax. Who Else Should Be?
86,000 People Pay 80% of Personal Income Tax. Who Else Should Be?
Nov 19, 2026 |

86,000 People Pay 80% of Personal Income Tax. Who Else Should Be?

The Inland Revenue Department Needs Staff to Pursue Evaders, and Employees Taxed at up to 36% Need Relief, Advisers at EY, Deloitte and KPMG Say

The government should step up enforcement against personal income tax evaders and give relief to salaried workers, tax advisers at EY, Deloitte and KPMG said ahead of the second reading of the 2027 budget.

Sulaiman Nishtar, partner and head of tax at EY, estimates that 40% of people who should pay per sonal income tax don’t. Rifka Ziyard, principal for tax and regu latory at KPMG, says employees cannot claim deductions like the self-employed can. Charmaine Tillekeratne, partner and head of tax at Deloitte, called for targeted relief for housing, education and health care costs.

Sri Lanka’s workforce is 7.9 million peo ple, 622,000 of whom pay APIT accord ing to the Inland Revenue Department’s 2025 data. However 80% of personal income taxes collected are paid by 86,000 people. How fair is the personal income tax system as far as APIT is con cerned? Is that important, and is that a factor to consider in taxation?

Charmaine Tillekeratne: One of the most important features of a good taxation system is equity and fairness. Advance Personal Income Tax (APIT) amounts to around 17% of total income tax collected. Non-corporate income taxes — advance withholding tax, APIT, and so on — make up 45% of total income tax collections.

With non-corporate income taxes, we are taxing an established base. This is easy to capture, as employers are required to deduct APIT. Whereas the incomes of the self-employed, professionals, and consult ants are difficult to capture.

There have been recent debates over whether the tax-free allowance should be increased, or whether the tax band should be widened. These are all good sugges tions. At the same time, we need to be mindful that we don’t want revenue to drop, even though some relief is needed for this category.

For example, if your salary is adjusted annually for inflation, that alone could push you into a higher tax bracket. Yet your real spending power has not changed.

How, then, can concessions be pro vided? My view is that this may not need to take the form of an enhanced tax-free allowance. Instead, we could look at tar geted reliefs — for housing, education expenditure, medical costs, and similar categories.

On the principle of fairness, how well does the current APIT structure stack up?

Rifka Ziyard: The rate ranges from 6% to 36%. From the common man’s perspec tive, at about Rs358,000 a month, you’re already hitting the 36% band. And because it’s employment income, there are no deductions. You are taxed on your gross pay, whereas a self-employed person can deduct expenditure.

At the end of the day, employees and professionals have no control over deduc tions. The fairness issue partly stems from the fact that the self-employed have deductions, but the salaried workforce does not. Most young, skilled professionals would be earning around Rs300,000.

That is just over $1000, right?

Ziyard: Exactly. So at that level of pay, you’re already hitting the top rate of 36%, and it becomes tempting to consider migration.

Whether it’s adjusting the income tax slabs or the rate, something has to give, because we need to retain our skilled pro fessionals.

It seems that there is no sense of fairness in how the slabs and rates are structured. As far as APIT is concerned, are you of the same view?

Suliman Nishtar: I have a slightly differ ent view on the rates. The rates and slabs are not exclusive to APIT. They apply to everyone who earns that income, whether employed or self-employed. If you make that net income, you pay the same tax. So it’s not targeted only at people in the APIT segment.

I believe many of those outside the APIT system are evading income tax, and even within the APIT system, based on my anal ysis, 40% of people are not paying. The government should be focused on bringing that 40% into the net.

They’ve introduced measures such as mandatory TIN (Tax Identification Number) requirements for major trans actions, but having a TIN doesn’t mean you’re paying tax. There is a huge limitation in terms of resources and ensuring compliance. Resources at the IRD (Inland Revenue Department) are stretched to a great extent. They should expedite recruitment to the department over the next 12 months.

Go after this 40%, and go after those who are not paying their full share. Bring them into the net.

If you could advise policymakers, as we are close to the second reading of the 2027 budget, would your advice be not to tinker with APIT rates, and instead double down on compliance?

Nishtar: The estimate is that 40% of people who should be paying personal income tax are not paying. I don’t think every one who should be paying corporate tax is doing so either, aside from a few. My advice would be to bring the rates down, provided we can bring everyone into the net. If everyone pays, everyone pays less.

I would set a 12-month target: set up a special unit at the IRD focused on collec tion, and go after evaders.

Do we have the grounds and conditions to do this?

Tillekeratne: We definitely have the leg islation supporting that. There are now options for instituting criminal proceed ings against those who evade the tax net.

The gap is in implementation, and in the IRD’s capacity to audit suspected evaders before instituting criminal proceedings. What’s needed is risk-based audits, gath ering and analysing data, and going after those completely outside the tax net.

Assuming someone’s been evading taxes, not APIT, but dodging personal income tax, what will happen to them now?

Nishtar: The department will have to take action. My advice would be for individu als to obtain professional advice. If your income is above the threshold, you are mandated to register and file a return. If your income is below the threshold and you can prove that, you may be able to avoid penalties for missing the filings. But if your income exceeds the threshold, you should immediately register for a TIN and file your return by this November. Failing to do so, the IRD can institute criminal proceedings.

Since the IRD captures information from banks, they can identify an indi vidual by their national ID number and see that no return has been filed, which immediately points to tax evasion. That is enough evidence for them to take action against you, after which you are at the mercy of the magistrate. So make sure to seek the right advice and take action to avoid potential imprisonment of up to six months.

If you haven’t paid for the last five years, they can go after the full amount. If you have filed a return, your protection comes from a 30-month time bar. If you haven’t filed a return, that protection is not available.

Does the IRD have access to your bank record history? If you’ve had a bank account for 20 years, would they now be able to access transaction history?

Nishtar: Correct. They can see all of your deposits and whatever balances you hold, against your account number and your national ID number.

Tillekeratne: In any event, they can call for it once they know your TIN and your bank account number.

Ziyard: They have the right to request information. What’s happening now is that there is an automatic feed of information from multiple parties, including banks and vehicle registration, among others. In addition, an IRD officer conducting an audit has the power to request specific information from banks.

The IRD has the power to assess, which basically means they can look at your bank accounts and examine your transac tions. Is this the assess ment you are referring to?

Ziyard: If you have not registered and obtained your TIN, if you have not filed a return, if you have been requested to meet an officer and did not comply, or if you have not presented requested documents, all of these can be identified as non-compliance, and all of them can fall under this criminalisation procedure.

What would happen is they will issue a notification requiring you to provide information within 30 days. If you don’t respond within 30 days, the commissioner general has the power to file a case at the magistrate court.

It then goes through the magistrate court procedure, where the judgment could be a fine, imprisonment, or both. Besides that, the commissioner general has the power, under the Inland Revenue Act, to raise an assessment without going to the magistrate court.

However, if you had filed a return and the IRD is not satisfied with it, they have 30 months within which to issue an assessment. If they do, you can appeal or request an administrative review, after which there is a further two-year period for the case to be heard. During that time, you can also have a discussion with the commissioner general and either agree to pay or contest it.

“We could allocate 20% of the proposed capital budget to adjust the personal income tax slabs and keep people here, especially those earning between Rs 200,000 and Rs 900,000 a month.”

If you do not agree, the next step in the appellate procedure is to go to the Tax Appeals Commission. That path has always existed. But the new power granted to the commissioner general is that they can now also file a case against you at the magistrate court.

Are we at a watershed? People have gotten used to a certain way of doing things, or not doing things. Do you think that is about to drastically change, in the context of personal income tax filings?

Nishtar: I think there has been a distinct improvement in people being worried, and in people wanting to pay. And if you are a high net worth individual, you don’t want this hanging over your head. For example, you have eight fixed deposits and have not declared two. It is not worth the embarrassment of going to court.

The IRD should enforce this, in my view, so that people get the message. If someone is repeatedly flouting the law, they should be taken to task.

How long have you been a tax consultant?

Nishtar: About 20 years now.

As someone with 20 years’ experience in tax consultancy at the highest level, you feel there is at least 40% non-com pliance. How much of that 40% non-com pliance do you think the current changes in the law address?

Nishtar: I think there has to be imple mentation, not just a change in the law. People need to see that the action, the implementation, is going to be strict.

The only question is whether this rate is fair, given the economic situation in the country, which is still coming out of a crisis. We were used to paying no APIT. APIT was removed at one point, so people got into lifestyles they couldn’t afford, and now changing that is tough.

And then, of course, for skilled pro fessionals, the opportunity to migrate is always there.

How long do you think it will take for non-compliance to fall from 40% to neg ligible levels?

Nishtar: I think it can be done in one year, if the IRD has the right resources. The IRD employs 1,000 to 1,200 people for a population of 22 million. For comparison, the Australian revenue authority employs 14,000 people. Our tax system is complex. You can’t run it with 1,000 people. We need a plan to upskill and recruit immediately, and to redeploy staff from overstaffed departments into the IRD.

Ziyard: There are about 7 million people in the workforce in Sri Lanka. 2.4 million are in the APIT system, but only 622,000 actually pay any tax. The rest don’t pay, as their income falls below the threshold.

The other aspect is compliance, or the return filing rate. Only 25% of individual taxpayers who should file tax returns actu ally do so by the deadline.

We’ve been talking about widening the net, and about the IRD’s lack of capacity as the reason we can’t widen it. Nothing much has changed, which is why I’m sceptical of your claim that we can fix the system in one year.

Ziyard: One of the key things is that there is a data overload. Perhaps by using AI, we can start to unscramble that scram bled egg. Someone gets a TIN, and after that, there are no letters, nothing. Nobody knows whether they’ve paid or not. It’s as if the system thinks, “You’re a ghost here.”

The Inland Revenue Department needs to have processes in place, with docu ments being circulated and potential tax collection being identified using the data they already have.

If somebody hasn’t been filing a return, and has an income above the tax-free threshold, they may be worried at this point. They will wonder, “If I file a return this year, what happens to the last 10 to 20 years when I also should have been paying tax, but haven’t?” What would you tell them?

Tillekeratne: They have no choice. It’s worse to keep evading. It’s better that they now assess their situation and voluntarily disclose it, because the alternative, staying quiet and then getting caught, is worse.

Will they have to pay all those taxes they’ve evaded over decades?

Tillekeratne: Yes, that’s possible. If you have wilfully evaded taxes, not filed tax returns, and not paid where you should have, the law allows the Inland Revenue authorities to go back as far as they want.

That’s how it works in theory. But if you voluntarily come forward and explain your situation, you may be able to negotiate, not for reduced taxes, but for a payment plan of some sort. They’ll likely give you that leeway, as long as you come forward voluntarily. But if you continue to evade, then once you are eventually caught, there will obviously be no leniency.

Let’s shift to the personal relief that you were talking about, Sulaiman [Nishtar].

Nishtar: We are losing a lot of people to migration. If you increase the tax slabs by another Rs200,000 each, what is the impact? Can we absorb that impact, given that we’re seeing revenue growth from customs, for example? What matters more, tax revenue or retaining the best human capital in the country?

I don’t think adjusting the slabs slightly is going to damage the government’s income stream, because we are already collecting a significant amount of revenue.

If you were to give the makers of the Budget ideas on personal income tax, what would they be?

Tillekeratne: Ask what people want. They want a house and a car; that’s their minimum lifestyle. On top of that, they want education for their children and healthcare for the family.

So you identify those areas, and identify which segments of individual taxpayers are vulnerable within them, unable to meet those basic needs because of rising taxes and falling purchasing power. Then grant tax relief, not by adjusting rates or bands, but through deductions such as the interest portion of a mortgage or children’s education expenses. That way, they make a saving, and they spend it on something productive.

“If your salary is adjusted annually for inflation, that alone could push you into a higher tax bracket. Yet your real spending power has not changed.”

Nishtar: We should look at what we can afford to do. We had ambitious revenue targets, and they have been achieved. It was mentioned recently that Rs2 trillion has been allocated for capital expenditure in 2027.

We need to decide what’s more impor tant, hard infrastructure or human capital. Some of that Rs2 trillion should go into protecting human capital. There’s little pur pose in all that infrastructure if our people leave the country. We could allocate 20% of the proposed capital budget to adjust the personal income tax slabs and keep people here, especially those earning between Rs200,000 and Rs900,000 a month.

I wouldn’t suggest giving specific allow ances now, because they’re complicated to track and complicated to audit, and people misuse deductions. So you need to keep it simple: give that group relief, and find the revenue somewhere else.

The share of people filing their tax returns on time is appallingly low. What does that say about the tax administration, and about how people approach tax?

Ziyard: It’s a split. Large taxpayers are about 90% compliant, according to 2024 figures. Everyone else is far behind.

Only 40 to 50% have filed a month after the process, connect these various sources of information, and make it easier for peo SULAIMAN NISHTAR PARTNER AND HEAD OF TAX, EY the deadline, rising to about 60% by the second month.

How fair is it for the Inland Revenue Act to impose criminal liability, and do you think that’s the right way to improve compliance?

Tillekeratne: The criminal provisions being in the law are meant as an extreme meas ure. The best way to improve compliance is not by frightening people. Instead, the message should be that if you voluntar ily come to us, for whatever reason you haven’t paid in the past, we will discuss it with you and see what we can do.

In the long term, we need to simplify the process, connect these various sources of information, and make it easier for people to comply. But in the short term, we have to send the message that it’s not all bad: come to us, and we’ll figure some thing out.

Are we rewarding non-compliance by suggesting that people can come in, sit down, and negotiate? Doesn’t that encourage everyone to simply wait until they hear from the department?

Nishtar: Simple things can be done, as in other countries, to improve compliance on filing. There is a provision to charge a Rs50,000 penalty if you don’t file on time. A very simple system could be imple mented: on the 1st of December, an email should be sent to everyone who hasn’t filed, stating that Rs50,000 is now due. From next year, every single person would file returns by the last day of November.

So forget criminal proceedings; the pen alty itself isn’t even being imposed. Then there’s late payment penalty and interest, which I also don’t know how effectively it is being implemented.

But the other factor is that while you can have all these processes in place, a sig nificant part of our economy runs on cash. When everything is done in cash, nothing comes into the bank, and no system picks it up. You can live your entire life on cash.

So there is a need to limit cash trans actions, as other countries have done: you shouldn’t be able to buy a car with cash, or a house with cash. It should be prohibited.

Right now, I could buy a house for Rs500 million with cash.

Is there anything we can do now that would appreciably simplify compliance?

Ziyard: One thing to do is address the issues in return filing. An individual also has to submit an assets and liabilities statement at the same time. The return itself has been simplified, but the assets and liabilities statement remains the same for everyone.

There is a specific format for this, where you have to declare your properties, cash balances, deposits, credit card balances, and so on. That now has to be filed by everybody. The issue is how safe this data actually is.

I think one of the key reasons a person is reluctant to file a return is the submis sion of these assets and liabilities dec larations. There is worry about who has access to this information, and how it will be used.

Sulaiman [Nishtar], are there any low-hanging fruit you think could sim plify tax?

Nishtar: Let’s say somebody is completely outside the system. I think there should be some transparency on how we are going to deal with that. We had a tax rate of 18%, half of today’s top rate, from around 2018 to about 2020.

Outstanding old taxes could be charged at half today’s rate. Penalties could be waived. It’s not an amnesty as such, but a move to improve compliance. Currently, the incentive to evade tax is a 36% benefit. For VAT, the incentive to evade is even greater, at 18%. The repercussions for evad ing are still unclear, and the repercussions for coming clean are also not clear.

People are cheating on their taxes, and nobody’s getting caught. The law is not entirely clear on what happens now. I think the IRD should provide some clarity.

Instead, we could say that if you file your return by November 30th, no ques tions will be asked. It’s like an amnesty, which isn’t the best solution, but some clarity is needed on the framework for how we would deal with you if you come clean.

Bringing the conversation back to the IRD going after people who are fairly compliant. Is that a problem in the sys tem at the moment?

Tillekeratne: The authorities probably need to use a risk-based audit before call ing for more information, and request that information only when they find a specific gap that needs investigating.

That would probably be a more progres sive approach, rather than looking at all high net worth individuals and requesting every possible piece of information, telling them, “We know you have the capacity to pay. We just want to see if you’re paying the right taxes.”

When you call for every possible detail under the sun from them, it’s obviously a hassle.

What is your opinion on going after the fairly compliant, Rifka [Ziyard]?

Ziyard: Everybody has to pay their fair share. I think everybody agrees on that. On high net worth individuals, though, I have a different perspective.

In the law, there’s a provision that if you pay 120% more than the previous year, and give an affidavit declaring that everything is correct, the Inland Revenue Department need not audit that file. That provision already exists.

For the IRD, all their internal Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are reve nue-driven. It’s all about the numbers: how much more have you collected? If you look at the news headlines, it’s about more revenue. Nobody talks about KPIs like how many new taxpayers have come into the net, or how much more compli ance there is.

Those are the kinds of KPIs that need to change. Even earlier, when we made the transition from SVAT to the VAT refund mechanism, one of the first things we said was that the attitude needed to change, and the KPI should be how fast you pro cess a VAT refund.

Things like that need to change inter nally at the IRD. Changing the KPIs will have an impact. Otherwise, we will kill the golden goose.

Sulaiman [Nishtar], do you think the KPIs are aligned in the way they should be for tax collectors?

I do think a good KPI system will defi nitely drive the behaviour that policy makers need.I do think a good KPI system will defi nitely drive the behaviour that policy makers need.

I also think going after high net worth individuals is a good strategy, because it covers a lot of ground given the lim ited resources at the IRD. While high net worth individuals should be looked at, they should not be harassed, because they carry a huge share of the income tax burden.

Our tax recovery is mostly through self-assessment. I think about 98% of our tax comes from that. You need to treat them with equal respect, and if there is an issue, you only look into that specific issue.

There used to be a tax called the Economic Service Charge (ESC), charged as a per centage of revenue, which helped bring companies on tax hol idays, and others not contributing income tax, into the net. Is this a sound policy to consider now, as the government looks to expand the net?

Tillekeratne: ESC came in at a time when we had a fairly large number of tax holidays in place, with the Board of Investment (BOI) and so on.

To a great extent, now that we have entered the IMF programme, all the tax holidays have been rationalised. We don’t have that many left. There are maybe a few old ones still existing, and some coming from the Port City. ESC, as you said, was charged on turnover; it was never a tax in itself. It was to be set off against your tax payable in future, and there was a certain number of years you could carry it forward.

If it wasn’t utilised within that period, it became a tax cost and was written off.

There were a few criticisms of this, because you give a tax holiday and then afterwards introduce a new tax. In any case, since tax holidays are now fewer, it’s no longer too relevant. There were also disputes over how it was to be set off, and how long the carry-forward period was, which ended up being a bit messy. That’s why it was eventually removed.

So, in terms of your question about companies making continuous losses, there are other mechanisms to look at to see if that is due to evasion. If there are companies that are making unreasonable losses, you can audit them and see what the reason is.

I understand small companies declare tax losses all the time. Is that because they aren’t truthful about their costs, or because they’re hiding revenue?

Nishtar: Hiding revenue is widespread among businesses that deal in cash, and a turnover tax won’t fix that. If the sales are hidden, there’s nothing to tax. That was the limit of the Economic Service Charge (ESC), a tax on turnover that was abolished in 2020.

On the cost side, you would normally audit to find out. But if overstating costs is common across an entire industry, and you don’t have the resources to audit everyone, a turnover tax makes it easy, because you collect regardless of the costs they claim.

In practice, the Social Security Contribution Levy (SSCL), introduced in October 2022, has probably taken over that role. It’s charged at 2.5% on turnover, so a business pays it on its sales even if it declares a loss. Unlike the ESC, it can’t be deducted from income tax, so it’s a permanent cost. Even companies on tax holidays, which exempt them from income tax to attract investment, pay it on what they sell locally, unless their activity is exempt. So there is now a tax on revenue, but it isn’t a minimum income tax; it’s an indirect tax.

What would be your closing thoughts ahead of the Budget?

Nishtar: The government and the IRD should make a strong push to bring peo ple into the tax net, not to harass them, but to make sure everyone pays their fair share. As more people come in and the revenue base grows, everyone can pay less tax overall. If it’s planned well, I think that can be done in three years.

But we need to be careful. We are still not out of the woods. One of the reasons for the crisis was people not paying their fair share, along with unnecessary con cessions [the 2019 tax cuts]. The rationale was that putting more money in people’s hands would lead to more spending and more VAT. That can work, but only if you have the buffers to absorb the revenue loss, and we had a lot going against us, from the Easter attacks to COVID to the economic crisis. We cannot afford to end up in that position again.

“Only 25% of individual taxpayers who should file tax returns actually do so by the deadline.”

Ziyard: Small and medium-sized enter prises (SMEs) need a reduced tax rate and a simpler way to comply. They are the growth engine of the economy, yet their rate went from 14% to 30%, the same as other companies, while sin industries such as alcohol and tobacco went from 40% to 45%. We need local entrepreneurs building businesses, scaling them and creating jobs. Just as we should invest in human capital, the government should support SMEs with a lower rate and simpler compliance, so that they and the informal sector come into the tax net.

Tillekeratne: My wish list would be a transparent plan, with milestones, for widening the tax base over the next one to three years. Every year, in every budget, we talk about widening the base, and about needing technology and skills to do it. Tax is a tool, and like any tool, it has to be used intelligently. We now have a Tax Policy Unit under the Finance Ministry. It should be used more to come up with a specific plan for broadening the tax base and simplifying the system. Otherwise, it’s just a recurring theme we keep talking about every year.

 

Most Popular

Advertisement
© 2026 Echelon Media (Pvt)Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
  • Features
  • Portfolio
  • Brand Voice
  • Innovation
  • Leadership
  • Public Policy
  • collection
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy